StoneX

ryad22

1-2 tahun

On average, how much time does it usually take for a StoneX withdrawal to reach your bank account or e-wallet?

WikiFXJawab

In my experience and based on the information available, I could not find any specific, transparent details regarding StoneX’s typical withdrawal processing times. This lack of disclosure immediately raised concerns for me, particularly as clear withdrawal procedures are a critical factor in assessing a broker’s reliability. As an independent trader, I’ve learned to be especially cautious with firms that don’t openly state their funding and withdrawal timelines, as this creates room for uncertainty and risk. What stood out for me was the recurring theme in user reports detailing significant withdrawal issues—delays, extra requirements, and even allegations of money being withheld until additional taxes or fees are paid. Several users described situations where withdrawal requests were frozen or subjected to unexpected hurdles, which is atypical for well-regulated or transparent brokers. In my view, these patterns, coupled with the fact that StoneX currently operates without valid regulatory oversight, make it impossible for me to provide any average or expected withdrawal timeframe with confidence. For traders considering StoneX, I strongly recommend being very cautious and thoroughly investigating all withdrawal conditions and the broker’s regulatory standing before depositing funds. In my opinion, the lack of clarity around withdrawals is a significant red flag and not something I’m comfortable risking my capital on.

Broker Issues

StoneX

Withdrawal

Deposit

2025-08-30

Amerika Serikat

Moshiheya

1-2 tahun

Does StoneX charge a commission for each lot traded on its ECN or raw spread accounts?

WikiFXJawab

Based on my review of StoneX as an experienced trader, I must highlight that the information currently available is quite limited and raises some critical concerns that shape my approach to fees and commissions. Specifically, StoneX does not provide transparent details regarding its fee structure, including whether it charges commissions per lot on any ECN or raw spread account types. This lack of clarity is something I always view with caution, as understanding the cost of each trade is fundamental for consistent trading performance and risk management. Additionally, it’s important to recognize that StoneX is not regulated by any recognized authority at this time. This absence of regulation, coupled with an unclear fee schedule and no mention of ECN or raw spread trading accounts, forces me to be especially conservative. In my experience, regulated brokers will always make their commission and spread structure very clear in their account details, as this is essential for both trust and compliance reasons. While StoneX does offer a demo account and a proprietary platform, these positives do not offset my concerns regarding the ambiguous pricing model. Without verified and transparent information about trading commissions or spreads for forex trading, I cannot comment definitively on the costs for each lot traded, and therefore, I would not proceed with live trading or significant capital commitments under such conditions.

Broker Issues

StoneX

Fees and Spreads

2025-08-14

Amerika Serikat

joalund

1-2 tahun

How do StoneX's swap fees (overnight financing charges) stack up against those charged by other brokers?

WikiFXJawab

Based on my experience and review of the available information, I have not found any clear or public data regarding StoneX's swap fees or specific overnight financing charges. This lack of transparency stands out for me compared to other brokers in the industry. With many of the brokers I’ve worked with, including some well-established ones, swap rates are usually detailed on either the platform itself or in the fee schedule, making it much easier for me to estimate my potential holding costs. At StoneX, not only is the fee structure unclear, but there’s also no direct mention of swaps or overnight charges in the published material. As an active trader, especially when engaging in strategies that require holding positions overnight, knowing these financing costs is critical for risk management and accurate profit calculations. The absence of such disclosure means I cannot directly compare StoneX’s swaps to those of other brokers, some of whom offer competitive and clearly stated rates. Furthermore, considering StoneX’s lack of regulatory oversight and the reported issues surrounding withdrawals and fees, I am personally even more cautious. For traders who rely on transparent costs and regulatory protection, this represents a significant drawback. Until StoneX provides explicit, verifiable information on their swap fees, I would advise a conservative approach and recommend only trading with brokers who are fully transparent and regulated regarding their overnight financing policies.

Broker Issues

StoneX

Fees and Spreads

2025-07-29

Amerika Serikat

Karoline Hardy

1-2 tahun

Is StoneX overseen by any regulatory bodies, and if so, which financial authorities are responsible for its regulation?

WikiFXJawab

As an experienced forex trader who values strict oversight in financial dealings, regulatory status is always a primary consideration for me before engaging with any broker. In my investigation of StoneX, I found that despite claims and some references to regulatory bodies like the FCA in the UK and the NFA in the US, StoneX is not currently under valid or verified regulation. The WikiFX data makes it clear that its regulatory licenses are marked as "unverified" or even "suspicious," and there is an explicit warning about the absence of effective regulatory oversight. In practice, this means there's no reputable authority—such as the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) or the US National Futures Association (NFA)—providing supervision over StoneX’s business activities. This distinction is critical because genuine regulatory oversight is what provides traders with safeguards, grievance redress, and a level of capital protection. Without it, the risk of encountering operational, withdrawal, or security issues increases substantially. Based on my experience, trading with unregulated or questionably regulated entities carries higher potential downside with little recourse in case of disputes or irregularities, so I personally would not be comfortable depositing funds or trading actively on such a platform.

Broker Issues

StoneX

Regulation

2025-07-26

Amerika Serikat